Every Educator Should Ask: How Much Farther Can We Go on the Road to Understanding the Human Mind?

At what historical juncture did Vygotsky join the discussion on "understanding the human mind"

One of the philosopher's major tasks is to explore how people think. Modern Education is likewise concerned with how children think and how we can influence their thinking, and so we cannot help but look at how philosophers throughout history have viewed this question.

Locke of the Enlightenment held that when a person comes into this world, the mind is like a "blank slate" (tabula rasa): people receive information from the environment through their sensory systems, which gives rise to thoughts in us, and therefore the environment we are in determines how we think. This epistemology is called empiricism. The view is no stranger to the public, and even today in early education we still emphasize sensory stimulation. Empiricism therefore holds that to find out how people think is to explore how people produce more complex and systematic ideas from simple sensory experiences.

The continental European philosophical tradition represented by Kant, on the other hand, holds that the human mind possesses an innate cognitive structure that enables us to process concepts such as time, space, and causality. Consequently, the world that people see can only be the world as we humans see it, rather than the "thing-in-itself."

Scientific study of the human being can only focus on his body, while philosophy is entrusted with the mission of attending to the human soul. As teachers rather than doctors, what we are concerned with naturally belongs to the "soul" side. Therefore, as educators, I think it is necessary to understand the history of philosophy and to comprehend these discussions: how the human mind comes into being, how the mind develops, what concrete forms the mind's manifestations take, and whether the boundaries of mental development can be delineated.

But beginning in the 1860s, with the appearance of three works, Darwin's Origin of Species, Gustav Fechner's Die Psychophysik, and I. M. Sechenov's Reflexes of the Brain, people began to explore the human mind from the perspective of biology and physiology. Attention to the mind was no longer based merely on philosophical discussion but on physiological experimental phenomena. Psychological phenomena were quantified and objectively measured, and psychological activity could be reduced to physiological processes of the nervous system. Therefore, an understanding of the human mind could no longer avoid research grounded in physiology, which is concretely manifested in attention to the development of psychology and neuroscience. At the same time, these three books further stimulated people to begin exploring:

1. Compared with animals, what is the essential difference in human behavior?

2. What is the relationship between the environment and the human mind?

3. What is the relationship between the physiological and the psychological processes?

In 1890s, Wilhelm Wundt began, through experiments, to try to clearly present the relationship between external stimuli and the emergence of human consciousness. However, he could only decompose consciousness as far as possible into simple sensory elements, and was unable to study higher human mental functions such as memory and reasoning, believing that these could only be resorted to through historical comparative study of cultural products. Research results under this research paradigm were bound to head toward barrenness. Yet decomposing human consciousness into the most immediate sensations or feelings has strong operability. For example, in educational practice, we often guide children to describe and define their own feelings as precisely as possible.

Psychology therefore abandoned this introspective, subjectivist research paradigm and turned to the study of behavior, trying to understand what kind of stimulus produces what kind of behavioral response. But in essence this is still the same as introspective psychology, that is, finding the connections between external stimuli and people's responses, and then synthesizing individual connections to analyze why people produce complex responses.

The behaviorist paradigm for understanding the human mind and behavior is also found everywhere in today's educational practice. The most obvious manifestation, for instance, is the relatively fixed daily routine.

Up to this point, psychology had still made no progress in the exploration of understanding higher human psychological processes. Psychology remained in this crisis for several decades, until the emergence of Marxism, when the Russian psychological community began to acknowledge that this theory was useful for understanding collective consciousness but could not explain individual consciousness. This was the historical background of psychology's development when Vygotsky began his psychological research.

Faced with this situation, Vygotsky opposed an "atomistic" analytical psychology, and also did not want psychology to split internally into two irreconcilable camps, namely the "natural science" paradigm based on physiology and the "mental science" that could only describe but could not explain the mental life of human beings.

And he had both keen insight and grand ambition regarding the development of this discipline: he held that to understand the human mind, we must both build on a physiological foundation, that is, investigate the brain mechanisms of specific cognitive functions, and understand how this cognitive function develops in an individual from simple to more complex stages. More importantly, we must acknowledge the influence of the historical, social, and cultural background. This conception sounds indeed perfect, but he himself ultimately knew clearly that he had not been able to realize this academic ambition. Yet his insight into the direction was undoubtedly profound.

In the following ten years of academic research, Vygotsky expended enormous effort solely to correct two widespread misconceptions:

  • First, the belief that people's higher psychological processes are the repeated accumulation of simple "stimulus-response" connections (mechanical combination of stimulus-response laws);

  • Second, the belief that children's development is a mechanism that waits for a particular moment to appear.

Yet these two views still exist like "common sense" in the minds of many education practitioners and parents.

Although he emphasized the physiological basis of psychological research, he held that ultimately we need to understand all of this on the basis of the Marxist theory of the history of human society (historical materialism). Marx's historical materialism holds that changes in the human mind depend on changes in social history. From the perspective of psychology, Vygotsky demonstrated the universal truth of this theory. For example, drawing on Engels's account of how people interact with the natural environment through labor and tools, Vygotsky extended the mediation of human–environment interaction from concrete tools to the use of abstract symbols, and further explained how the use of symbolic tools, such as language, affects the development of the human mind. In essence, this is an exploration of through what mechanisms culture becomes part of the individual's nature.

It can be seen that all the efforts they made were for the sake of understanding the human mind itself and its laws of development.

As educators, our daily practice, consciously or unconsciously, hopes to guide the development of the human mind at the concrete, micro level, especially through symbolic systems. But the historical and cultural background of the era in which Vygotsky's theory arose and that of today have undergone enormous changes, and we need to take the initiative to shoulder the responsibility of our own era. Nevertheless, the theoretical perspective he offers remains ever fresh. Moreover, compared with explorations of the human mind based on a physiological foundation, sociohistorical-cultural psychology is undoubtedly the theoretical foundation that enables education to realize its greatest potential.

Previous
Previous

Psychology Can Define the Human Mind, but Literature Coexists with It